Restaurants

Not Justa Diner

4.2 199 reviews 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM 1961 US-8, St Croix Falls, WI 54024, United States

Discover this place

Nestled in St. Croix Falls, Not Justa Diner is a hidden gem that elevates classic diner fare with a unique twist. The atmosphere is welcoming, and diners rave about the hearty portions and honest pricing. Signature dishes like the crispy homemade hash browns and flavorful biscuits and gravy have garnered praise, with one reviewer noting a delightful peppery kick that enhances the experience. The menu caters to both breakfast aficionados and dinner seekers, featuring everything from towering pancakes to satisfying Greek salads. Feedback from guests indicates that the service is warm and attentive, with many highlighting the staff's readiness to accommodate dietary preferences. Whether it’s a crispy basket of fries or a classic country fried steak, the food consistently aims to please. Special mention goes to their hangover hash, celebrated for its fresh, well-balanced flavors—an embodiment of the dinner's dedication to quality from scratch. Overall, Not Justa Diner stands out as a nostalgic yet refreshing take on the traditional diner, making it an essential stop for anyone traveling through the area. If you value savory, satisfying food and genuine service, this diner is not to be missed.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great coffee
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Not Justa Diner before visiting.

Reviews for Not Justa Diner

4.2

199 reviews

100%

19%

14%

Review highlights

Based on 199 reviews

Not Justa Diner in St Croix Falls is frequently praised for its generous portions, flavorful dishes, and a menu that offers a creative twist on classic breakfast and comfort foods. Reviewers commonly highlight the quality and freshness of the food, with particular appreciation for standout items like crispy hashbrowns and hearty biscuits and gravy. The restaurant is noted for its accommodating service, especially in catering to dietary preferences, and maintaining a friendly, old-fashioned roadhouse atmosphere. While most feedback is positive regarding food and service, some diners express mixed feelings about certain specials. Overall, the combination of reasonable pricing, ample servings, and attentive staff contributes to its reputation as a reliable and satisfying stop for travelers and locals alike.

Sam Brown

May 26, 2025

Best hashbrowns, very crispy! Also the biscuits & gravy were sooo good, very peppery & full of flavor.

Angelina Pronto

May 18, 2025

We were passing through Friday on the way to the cabin and needed dinner. I had the Greek salad, my husband ordered the fish special, my daughter had a pancake & my son had a fancy grilled cheese. My salad was huge with lots of tzatziki and fed 2 people. The fish was not very good but the potatoes were just like grandma makes. You only need 1 pancake because it’s platter sized. The sandwich was lovely

Paul Salwasser

May 13, 2025

I have had 3 breakfasts here in last two years and they were all very flavorfull and freshly prepared from scratch. the hangover hash I had yesterday was especially memorable. I recommend eating here for tasty food, honest service, good prices and the old fashioned, but remade wisconsin roadhouse breakfast cafe. its a step above the standard fried eggs and bacon place - all the items have a unique savory flavor thats makes this a great experience. eat here, places like these are rare these days.

Leslie Richter

May 10, 2025

I've never been disappointed. I have waited till I visited many times to write this review. The price is right, the food is plentiful and good. As a person who can't eat pork, I am happy to say that they will adjust to help. I always love the service. If your traveling through St. Croix you will be happy to pause at Not Justa Diner/Not Justa Etc.

Secret

Mar 21, 2025

The customer service here was awesome with Abby. I've heard complaints, about other servers, but my party of 5 had no issues. Our server was patient, understanding and got everything we ordered right. The food was hot, drinks were cold and our coffee cups stayed full! The food was delicious, we were given quite a bit of food actually and the prices were not outrageous. If you have never visited this location, you might want to check it out!!!

David Ducharme

Mar 08, 2025

Great service because they had enough staff who were friendly and knowledgeable. Got a 3 burger on Monday. It was so good I got a second to go!

Larry Hollar

Mar 03, 2025

Breakfast was good, even the eggs-over-medium. I walked right to my seat and was served quickly. The hash browns were crispy as they should be. I ordered just what I wanted, ignoring the menu suggestions. Besides the diner area there are some gift offerings. I’ll go back if I’m nearby.

Cocaine “Coke” Gallmeyer

Feb 17, 2025

Great friendly atmosphere, our waitress was great and efficient. Our food was delicious and the portions were very generous. Thier turkey club is amazing and my husband had the Denver omelet which comes with hash browns and two pieces of toast. Pricing is also great. The little shop has unique items also. We will definitely be returning soon and highly recommend this diner!!!